Duke University
Center for the Study of Aging and Human Development

     
       
Geri Home Page

Computing & Statistics Lab

                 Regarding Windows XP Service Pack 3
 
     Microsoft recently released SP 3 for Windows XP. It is primarily a 
compilation of the many Windows Updates that have occured since Service 
Pack 2 was released three and a half years ago. There are only four new 
features, which most users will not notice.
 
     The articles that I have read are pretty much positive. The 
discussion at the LAN administrators' meeting yesterday was non-committal, 
in that there are no big risks and no big gains.
 
     The following quote sums it up:
          "All things considered, Windows XP Service Pack 3 
           proves to be a fairly anticlimactic final release
           in the XP service pack line. It won’t blow up your
           computer, but it won’t make it very much better, either."
      from - http://blogs.pcworld.com/staffblog/archives/006526.html
 
Downsides:
1. You cannot uninstall Internet Explorer version 7 without uninstalling 
   the entire service pack.
2. Breaks some computers that use the AMD microprocessor, mostly HP and 
   Compaq computers. Look for the "Intel Inside" sticker on the front of 
   your computer.
3. It takes about an hour over a high speed connection if you manually 
   run Windows Updates from Internet Explorer.
 
Upsides:
1. Keeping up with all current software versions is mandated by Duke 
   security policies.
2. You can continue to leave automatic updates enabled without repeatedly 
   being bugged to update to Service Pack 3.
3. Some people report that their computer performs faster.
 
Recommendation:
1. Leave automatic updates enabled to get Service Pack 3 when Microsoft 
   automatically sends it later in the summer.

Released: May 15, 2008
  
About Us | Weekly Bulletin | Center Report | People | Research | Education | Service | Pepper Grant | Links | DUMC | Duke
Copyright 2004 Duke University Center for the Study of Aging and Human Development

Questions or Comments? Contact Webmaster